Let’s face it: choosing an engagement ring is a high-stakes endeavor. You’re not just picking out a piece of jewelry. You’re choosing a tiny, sparkling emblem of love that says, “I know you better than you know yourself.” No pressure, right?
But here’s the thing: You don’t have to know every little detail. In fact, sometimes, you can figure out everything you need to know just by paying attention. Trust us—every single clue is right there in front of you. Let’s break it down, one overly significant question at a time.
What Type of Person Are They?
This is where you start. Forget diamonds for a second—think about them. Who are they?
Are they The Practical One? They’re the kind of person who organizes their sock drawer and makes lists for fun. They read reviews before buying toothpaste. This is the person who has one pair of diamond studs that they wear everyday AND clean every night. They want something simple, timeless, and foolproof. Think a classic solitaire or three-stone ring.
Are they The Easygoing One? They’re casual, cool, and not only perfectly happy, but oh so chic in jeans and a sweater. A telltale sign of easygoing is the type of watch they wear - this is not the Apple watch person, this is the simple leather band with maybe a simple tennis bracelet next to it. Go for something understated—maybe a minimalist band or a pop of color with a gemstone.
Are they The “I’m One of a Kind” Type: They’re unique, bold, and a little unpredictable. This is the kind of person who scours Etsy on the regular for every single thing in the house. Nothing is brand new unless it’s custom - they wouldn’t be found dead with the same anything as anyone else. They want something that stands out— mixed-metals, colorful stones, definitely something with a vintage twist.
What Do They Like to Do?
Lifestyle matters, people. This ring has to fit into their life—not just their finger.
Are they The Indoorsy Type? They love books, puzzles, or baking the perfect loaf of sourdough. Take a look at their bookshelf - Jane Austen? Nora Ephron? Intro to Bread Baking? You’re on the right path - they’d appreciate something intricate, romantic, and a little old-fashioned.
Are they The Outdoorsy Type? They’re hiking, running, or rescuing stray cats from trees. Do they get excited when the LL Bean catalogue comes every month? Check their shoe closet - more than one pair of outdoor activity specific shoes? Think durable and low-profile—something that won’t snag on a backpack or a climbing harness.
Where is their Dream Vacation?
Your partner’s dream travel destination says more about them than you might think. It’s not just where they want to go—it’s how they see the world and what they value.
The Mountain Lover: They dream of crisp air, cozy cabins, and breathtaking views. They talk about hiking in the Alps, sipping coffee on a porch overlooking a valley, or living off-grid one day? This is your sign. This person is grounded, peaceful, and deeply in tune with nature. A rose gold band with earthy gemstones like smoky quartz, citrine, or even a raw diamond will resonate with their love of the outdoors.
Actually, let's forget about rings for a second - if this is your vibe as a couple, you might want to check out The Black Oak Mountain Vineyards - one of our favorite venues to celebrate this huge milestone in your life.
Picture yourselves saying “I do” against rolling hills, with the kind of golden sunset in the background that makes even the most cynical among us believe in happily ever after. A Black Oak Mountain Winery wedding has the effortless elegance required for the couple who can make flannel look chic during a champagne toast. The expansiveness of Black Oak Mountain Winery is breathtaking - a venue that allows you to start this new chapter of your life among the mountain breezes and the serenity of nature, without compromising a lick of sophistication.
Sorry, not sorry, for the tangent. We just can't help ourselves when an opportunity like this arises!
The Beachgoer: Have they saved vacation photos of turquoise water and white sandy beaches on their Pinterest board? This is a person drawn to the sea, to warmth and light. Their perfect ring might feature an aquamarine (blue like the ocean) or an opal that shimmers like sunlight on water. Pair it with a white gold or platinum band for an airy, fresh feel.
The Urban Explorer: Do they rave about trips to New York, Paris, or Tokyo? If they can’t stop talking about architecture or street style, they’re a city lover through and through. If they’re into bustling cities, modern art, and rooftop bars, sleek and contemporary styles are their thing. Think baguette or emerald-cut diamonds in platinum settings.
The Romantic Countryside Dreamer: If they’ve ever said, “I just want a quiet cottage one day,” this is a person who dreams of soft meadows, rolling hills, and pastoral charm? This person might love vintage-inspired rings with intricate filigree details or floral motifs. Gemstones like morganite or pastel sapphires add a romantic touch.
What is their Metal of Choice?
The metal of the band is like the foundation of a house—it sets the tone for the entire ring. Choosing the right metal is about balancing their style, lifestyle, and personality. Here’s how to decode their preferences:
Yellow Gold: A warm, timeless choice that radiates classic elegance. Yellow gold has been a favorite for centuries and is perfect for someone who appreciates tradition with a hint of nostalgia. We see yellow gold often on people who love vintage styles or has a wardrobe full of earthy tones and warm colors.
White Gold: Modern and sleek, white gold is a versatile choice for someone who loves a minimalist, clean aesthetic. It’s especially popular in contemporary designs. White gold is a great choice for someone who loves polished, understated looks and enjoys giving tradition a modern twist. Is their style crisp and tailored? White gold is likely a strong contender!
Rose Gold: Romantic and unexpected, rose gold is a softer, more unique metal that suits someone with a creative or sentimental personality. Its blush tone adds a warm, feminine touch. Rose gold is perfect for someone who values individuality and isn’t afraid to stray from the traditional towards more whimsical or vintage inspired designs.
Platinum: Known for its durability and rarity, platinum is the ultimate choice for someone who values strength and luxury. Its silvery-white sheen is timeless and refined. If your person is practical, yet drawn to the finer things in life and appreciate things that blend beauty with functionality, platinum is a good way to go.
Mixed Metals: For the rule-breaker who doesn’t like to play by the book, mixed metals add an edgy, versatile touch. Pairing different metal colors (e.g., yellow gold with white gold or platinum) makes for a bold, one-of-a-kind look. Do they already mix and match jewelry, layering silver bracelets with gold necklaces? If their motto is “why choose one when you can have both,” mixed metals might be the answer.
_____
What’s Their Stone?
Diamonds are the default - but sometimes you want to add a little something extra or swap it for something more unique all together!
Diamond: The classic choice. They love sparkle, tradition, and a sense of timelessness. You honestly can never go wrong with a diamond - so when in doubt, a diamond should be the hero stone of your ring.
Emerald: Vibrant green, elegant, and full of depth. This is perfect for someone who loves a touch of drama and sophistication.
Ruby: Do they gravitate toward deep red hues in clothing or décor? Have they ever called something “fiery” in a good way? Bold, passionate, and deeply romantic, rubies symbolize love and courage and perfect for those who thrive on intensity and charm.
Sapphire: Regal and versatile, sapphires come in shades of deep blue and even pinks and yellows. They’re for someone who exudes a classical elegance but isn’t afraid to stand out. If this sounds like them or they have a love for history (Princess Diana, anyone?) or appreciate subtle luxury, sapphire is an excellent choice.
Opal: Have they ever described something as “magical” with genuine enthusiasm? Ethereal and unique, opals seem to glow from within. Ideal for the dreamer, the artist, or the free spirit - this is a great stone for the person who often describes things as “magical” with genuine enthusiasm.
How Many Stones?
Think of this as a question of personality. Are they all about simplicity, or do they lean toward making a statement?
Single Stone: Timeless, elegant, and focused. If they prefer understated jewelry and classic wardrobe staples (think tailored coats and little black dresses), go with one central stone. A single gemstone says, “Let’s keep it simple—and stunning.”
Three Stones: Romantic and meaningful, three-stone rings symbolize the past, present, and future. This is the ring for those who save old movie ticket stubs, press flowers in books, and tear up over anniversary speeches. It’s a sentimental choice for someone who loves tradition but with a touch of storytelling.
Multiple Stones: Bold and unapologetically glamorous. Are they the life of the party, the one with the iconic laugh and a closet full of statement pieces? A multi-stone ring is perfect for someone like this - a person who loves being the center of attention (and frankly, deserves it).
What’s Their Era?
If your partner could time-travel to another era, where would they go? Their answer could say everything about their ring style.
Art Deco: This is for someone who loves bold, geometric shapes and vintage glamor. Do they love black-and-white movies, flapper dresses, or jazz? You’re in the right place. Think Gatsby-esque elegance with a diamond that looks like it belongs in a speakeasy.
Victorian: Romantic and ornate, with intricate details and floral designs. This era is for someone who dreams of grand love letters and candlelit evenings. If they’ve ever referred to something as “whimsical,” a Victorian-style ring is probably perfect.
Retro: Bold and playful designs, often featuring yellow gold and statement gems. Are they into vintage furniture, retro sunglasses, or statement lipstick? Yep, Retro is the way to go. 
Modern: Sleek and minimalist, these rings are perfect for someone who loves clean lines and contemporary aesthetics. If their Instagram feed is full of minimalist interiors and black-and-white photography, Modern is calling.
Here’s the secret: No matter what ring you choose, they’ll love it. Because you chose it. And honestly, if you’re putting this much thought into the process, you’re already doing it right. And if you’re really worried - just bring them into the process. It is 2025 after all!
So go ahead—get the ring. And when they say “yes,” you can finally breathe again. Or maybe not. After all, now you’ve got a wedding to plan.