A Guide to Selecting Your Perfect Vintage Engagement Ring

We may be biased, but isn’t there something just so incredibly magical about vintage engagement rings? Think about it - they’re not just symbols of love but also carry sweet whispers of romance, of bygone eras, of true love stories. We know that when you're on the hunt for that perfect vintage engagement ring, you’re not just shopping for a piece of jewelry—you’re stepping into history, seeking out a moment in time and choosing a piece that speaks to the depths of your soul. The world of vintage engagement rings is so vast that the challenge is often where to even begin the search! With so many different styles, stones, and metals, the vintage jewelry world can feel a little overwhelming. Fear not, dear seeker! This guide will walk you through the world of vintage engagement rings, helping you find the one that feels as unique as your love story.

What Defines Vintage?

Before we dive into the details, let’s first get a handle on what makes a ring "vintage." Simply put, a vintage engagement ring is between twenty and ninety-nine years old.  Unlike modern or antique rings (the latter being over 100 years old), vintage rings capture the essence of specific past eras, like the Art Deco period of the 1920s or the bold styles of the 1970s.

It's not just about age, though. Style plays a big role too. Vintage rings often feature unique design elements, such as intricate filigree, bold geometric shapes, and milgrain detailing. These rings can be ornate or simple, but they always offer a certain charm that sets them apart from their modern counterparts.

Now that you know what makes a ring vintage, let's explore some of the most popular styles and types of vintage engagement rings based on metal and stones. Each has its own special allure and unique care needs.

Vintage Diamond Engagement Rings: The Nuances

Diamonds are timeless, but vintage diamond engagement rings bring something extra to the table. These rings often feature diamonds cut in ways not commonly found today, like the Old European Cut or the Rose Cut. These cuts give diamonds a softer, more romantic sparkle compared to the sharper brilliance of modern cuts like the Round Brilliant.

When you're choosing a vintage diamond ring, pay attention to the setting. Many vintage rings feature intricate settings that showcase the stone in a delicate, unique way. The setting can also indicate the ring’s era. For example, Art Deco settings (1920s-1930s) are known for their symmetrical and geometric designs, while Edwardian-era rings (early 1900s) often incorporate lace-like details and filigree work.


What to Look For in a Vintage Diamond Engagement Ring

There are many basics to keep in mind when looking for an engagement ring, but a few extra watchouts when looking for something vintage.

Era: As described above, it's important to have an understanding of what era you might like from a design perspective. This narrows the field a bit and allows you to focus on quality. Stay tuned for a blog that outlines all of the eras in detail! 

Cut: Check for vintage diamond cuts that give the stone its character. Old European and Rose Cuts are charming, but make sure they have been well-preserved.

Setting: The setting can be a giveaway of the ring’s age and adds a lot of personality. It is critical to ensure that the setting is secure as it is normal for older rings to lose a bit of security over time. But fret not, this is easily fixed by a good jeweler! 

But it’s not just about the purchase, it’s about ensuring that when it becomes yours, you are caring for it - vintage diamond rings need regular care to ensure the setting remains secure. Gentle cleaning and professional checks are a must.

Vintage Emerald Engagement Rings: Make Them Green with Envy

We often think about engagement rings as diamond specific, but the truth is there is a whole world full of other precious gems. We happen to love the mystical quality of emeralds—their deep green hues seem to glow with an inner light. Vintage emerald engagement rings are perfect for someone who wants a ring that stands out from the crowd. Emeralds are softer than diamonds, making them more prone to scratches, so you’ll want to be extra cautious with daily wear.

Emeralds were especially popular during the Victorian and Edwardian eras, often paired with intricate gold settings. In some rings, you might find emeralds alongside diamonds or pearls, giving the ring a regal, old-world vibe.

What to Look For:

Color: The richer and deeper the green, the more valuable the emerald. Vintage rings may feature emeralds with slight imperfections or inclusions, which are natural and add character.

Setting: Since emeralds are softer, they need a secure setting. Be sure to inspect vintage emerald rings closely for any loose stones or worn prongs.

 

When it comes to care of emeralds, it’s important to avoid harsh chemicals when cleaning emerald rings. These stones need delicate care—mild soap and water will do just fine.

The Metal Makes It: Choosing the Setting for Your Vintage Engagement Ring

Gold is a classic choice for engagement rings, and vintage gold engagement rings offer a variety of shades and styles, from traditional yellow gold to more romantic hues like rose gold. Vintage gold rings often showcase hand-crafted details that you won’t find in modern designs. Whether it’s milgrain edges, engraved bands, or bold settings, vintage gold rings teem with character.

A vintage yellow gold engagement ring gives off a warm, timeless glow and is perfect for someone who loves classic elegance. Meanwhile, vintage rose gold engagement rings have a softer, romantic feel that works beautifully with both diamonds and colored stones. Rose gold was especially popular during the 1920s and has made a resurgence in recent years.

For those who prefer a cooler tone, white gold and platinum are beautiful options. White gold rings offer a sleek, modern look with a vintage twist and pair well with nearly any gemstone. Though they look similar, platinum is naturally white and doesn’t need the rhodium plating often applied to white gold, making it slightly more durable and hypoallergenic. Platinum is also highly resistant to tarnish, which means vintage platinum rings often retain their original luster, even after decades. Both metals offer a sophisticated, understated appeal that complements the sparkle of diamonds and the depth of colored gemstones alike.

What to Look For:

Quality: For gold, look for hallmarks indicating the metal’s purity, such as 14K, 18K, or 24K. For platinum, keep an eye out for hallmarks like "PLAT" or "950," which confirm its authenticity and high purity. White gold, like yellow and rose gold, also comes in 14K and 18K options, so check for these marks to gauge quality.

Wear and Tear: Over time, gold can become scratched or worn, especially in vintage pieces. Similarly, white gold, which often has a rhodium plating to enhance its shine, may need re-plating to maintain its brightness. Platinum, on the other hand, is highly durable and resistant to tarnish, though it can develop a natural patina that adds to its vintage charm. Check all metals for any signs of thinning, bending, or loose settings.

While gold is relatively easy to maintain with regular polishing, white gold may occasionally need re-plating to keep its luster. Platinum requires minimal maintenance but can benefit from occasional cleaning and polishing to restore its original shine. Regularly inspect all settings to ensure the stones are secure, regardless of the metal.

 

Tips for Buying Vintage Engagement Rings

Shopping for a vintage engagement ring can be fun, but it requires some research. Here are a few tips to guide you through the process:

Do Your Research: Understand the different eras (Art Deco, Victorian, Edwardian, etc.) and their design trends. This can help you identify the period a ring comes from and whether it fits your style. Take a look at the rings previous Trumpet & Horn couples have made for inspiration. 

Check for Authenticity: Look for hallmarks and certifications. These will confirm the authenticity and quality of the metal and stones.

Examine Condition: Vintage rings may have wear and tear, which is part of their charm. However, make sure any damage (like loose stones or thinning bands) can be repaired or doesn’t affect the integrity of the ring.

Consider Customization: If you fall in love with a vintage setting but the stone isn’t to your liking, many jewelers offer services to replace the stone while keeping the original design.

Work with a Reputable Dealer: Buy from trusted sellers like Trumpet & Horn, who specialize in vintage rings and can provide you with detailed information about the piece’s history and condition. In fact - have you made it this far? Why not just set up an appointment with us to chat about finding the perfect vintage engagement ring for you? 


In the end, selecting a vintage engagement ring is all about finding a piece that resonates with you and tells your unique love story. Whether you're drawn to the geometric cuts of the Art Deco era or the elegant simplicity of the Mid-Century, there’s a vintage engagement ring out there for you. So why settle for ordinary when you can wear a piece of history? Explore the stunning selection of vintage engagement rings today and find a ring that’s as timeless as your love! Or better yet, get in touch with us here at Trumpet & Horn to let us help you find the ring of their dreams.