Colored Gemstone Engagement Rings

We have a special place in our hearts for colored gemstone engagement rings, so we make sure to always have a large selection of unique colored gemstones in our ever growing collection of vintage engagement rings and fine jewelry. While sapphires, emeralds, and rubies are certainly the most well-known colored gemstones, we also seek out engagement rings made of tourmaline, jade, amethyst, citrine, opal, and turquoise, among other precious and semi-precious gemstones.

38 products

SOLD OUT
1.63 Carat Sapphire and Diamond 18k White Gold Ring

1.63 Carat Sapphire and Diamond 18k White Gold Ring
$ 3,200
$ 3,200
SOLD OUT
Paraiba Three Stone Gold Ring

Paraiba Three Stone Gold Ring
$ 5,500
$ 5,500
SOLD OUT
Antique Cushion Sapphire & Diamond Halo Engagement Ring | Tiffindell

Tiffindell
$ 3,450
$ 3,450
Rowan Circle

Rowan Circle
$ 2,400
$ 2,400
SOLD OUT
1960s Bulbous Gold & Amethyst Cocktail Ring | Brandywine

Brandywine
$ 1,700
$ 1,700
Wolcott

Wolcott
$ 3,450
$ 3,450
SOLD OUT
Vintage Victorian Sapphire & Diamond Halo Engagement Ring | Sunderland

Sunderland
$ 8,800
$ 8,800
SOLD OUT
Antique Art Nouveau Pearl & Diamond Flower Ring | Dolis

Dolis
$ 1,850
$ 1,850
SOLD OUT
1.50ct Cornflower Bllue Sapphire Solitaire Engagement Ring | Dunton

Dunton
$ 2,300
$ 2,300
Vintage Art Deco 2.50ct Sapphire & Diamond Halo Ring| Renway

Renway
$ 3,750
$ 3,750
Art Deco 1.45ct Old European Diamond & Onyx Vintage Ring | Kingspire

Kingspire
$ 8,200
$ 8,200
Vintage 1.87ct Cushion Sapphire & Diamond Ballerina Ring | Burroughs

Burroughs
$ 10,500
$ 10,500
SOLD OUT
1.01ct Two-Tone Emerald & Diamond Toi et Moi Ring | Sausalito

Sausalito
$ 8,500
$ 8,500
SOLD OUT
3.94ct Old Mine Cut Diamond & Pearl Art Deco Toi et Moi Ring | Everton

Everton
$ 67,500
$ 67,500
Serpentine Fancy Brown

Serpentine Fancy Brown
$ 1,850
$ 1,850
Emerald Serpentine

Emerald Serpentine
from $ 1,450
from $ 1,450
Antique Marcus & Co. 1.72ct Three-Stone Old European Cut Diamond & Demantoid Garnet Halo Ring | Triquetra

Triquetra
$ 26,000
$ 26,000
Vintage Mid Century Jade & Diamond Engagement Ring | Amboise

Amboise
$ 3,650
$ 3,650
Modern 8.50ct Citrine & Tanzanite Ring by Milanese Antonini Jewelry

Antonini
$ 4,200
$ 4,200
SOLD OUT
1.75ct Ruby & Diamond Buckle Ring from the 1980s | Palmoa

Palmoa
$ 3,800
$ 3,800
Modern East-West 4.36ct Blue Topaz & Half Moon Rhodalite Garnet Ring | Kew Gardens

Kew Gardens
$ 3,750
$ 3,750
0.83ct Art Deco Inspired Emerald & Diamond Ring | Glendalough

Glendalough
$ 4,650
$ 4,650
SOLD OUT
Antique Emerald & Diamond Three Stone with Old Mine Cut & OEC Poromiel

Poromiel
$ 1,500
$ 1,500
Vintage 4.24ct Aquamarine & Diamond Halo Ring | Skymeadow

Skymeadow
$ 4,125
$ 4,125
Knightdale

Knightdale
$ 1,050
$ 1,050
Belmonte

Belmonte
$ 14,500
$ 14,500
Tannyhill

Tannyhill
$ 12,500
$ 12,500
SOLD OUT
Tatenhill

Tatenhill
$ 1,450
$ 1,450